Make sure that you are signed up for the Prudent Money Newsletter. I am sending out my annual probabilities for 2009 this week. I don’t predict. I just write about what I feel are the highest probabilities to occur.
I have heard time and time again that the Government has to do everything in its power to prevent a deflationary recession. They desperately want you to think that we they are winning the fight against deflation. What they don’t want you to know is that deflation is here and that battle has been lost.
The minutes from the last Federal Reserve Board meeting revealed some deep concern. Their notes signaled that “the recession could be longer and deeper than officials previously thought, with unemployment rising into next year and inflation slowing substantially” (another way of saying deflation).
First, a few definitions would be helpful.
A normal recession is one in which the economy goes through a period of weakness and then bounces back and starts a brand new growth cycle. The growth in the economy contracts for two quarters at a minimum. There is some pain for the economy. However, it is not that bad.
A deflationary recession is a much bigger recession. Deflationary recessions are characterized mainly by falling prices and values of everything. Think of a normal recession as a Category 3 hurricane and a deflationary recession as a Category 4 hurricane.
We should not be hoping we avoid a deflationary recession. We should be hoping that the deflationary recession that is already here does not take hold like the one did in the 30’s in the US and the 90’s in Japan or transition from a deflationary recession into a depression (Category 5 hurricane).
It is hard to understand how any economist can look at this current environment and not come to the conclusion that we are in a deflationary recession. You can see deflation in the stock market, real estate, the destruction of credit, the unwinding of the debt bubble, consumer prices on retail goods, the price of oil, consumer confidence, etc.
The unemployment numbers that came out on Friday emphasize the problem that we are facing. We lost 524,000 jobs in December. They revised the numbers for the prior two months and added another roughly 160,000 in losses. This made 2008 the worst year since 1945. We lost over 2.5 million jobs in 2008 and that was after the Government estimated in their numbers that we had created 904,000 jobs. The unemployment rate stands at 7.2%. Unfortunately, I think that this unemployment rate will easily be north of 10% before this is over.
The work week is averaging 33.3 hours. That is the lowest on record. Another sign of deflation came out on Thursday with the consumer borrowing numbers. In November, consumer borrowing contracted by 7.4 billion dollars (another record).
My biggest concern is that the investor is drinking the Kool-aid that the worst is behind us and this is the greatest buying opportunity ever for the US investor. Financial media is acting as if this is a normal situation where everything is at the bottom and it only gets better going forward.
Continue to be careful with the risk that you take. It looks to me like the bear market rally that started in November ended at the end of December and we are heading back into the bear market again.
Tags: Bob Brooks, consumer confidence, credit, Deceptive Money, deflation, Deflationary recession, Depression, detb bubble, economist, Federal Reserve Board, Government, inflation, jobs, Newsletter, normal recession, Prudent Money, real estate, recession, Unemployment, unemployment rate
Recent Comments